The country crooner and his family are taking themed nights to the next level with their Godfather dinner, dressing to the nines for the occasion. McGraw shared a little peek at the evening on Instagram on Wednesday, Dec. 14, and even without knowing the menu, we’re crossing our fingers for an invitation—it would be an offer we couldn’t refuse! “‘The Godfather’ dinner theme night last night…” he captioned the Instagram Reel. “Love my family and all the craziness that comes with it!” The video featured a couple of quick snaps from the festive meal, set to what sounds like Nino Roto’s “Apollonia” with a full band. The first, filtered in black-and-white, found the family posing in front of the Christmas tree, all dressed in various Hollywood mob styles—from bowler hats, to wifebeaters and suspenders, to vests and fitted blazers. The second found the group crowding in for a mirror selfie, one of the girls donning a fake black mustache. “What a dramatic zoom out. For Oscar consideration,” his daughter Audrey wrote, seemingly making fun of his editing skills. Actor Eric Nelson wrote, “Literally doesn’t get any better. This is my kinda family vibes 💥” “Who woke up with the horse head in their bed?” one fan joked, and not to come off as desperate but, once again, we volunteer!